Slugline: Transcending cliches by refusing to let go of the gag.
Itoshiki is a new teacher, but he is anything but excited by the challenge of his school and students. In fact, on the way to the school he tries to commit suicide by hanging himself, but a student saves him from trying to 'grow taller.' Having had family members attempt to 'grow taller' is something that the student gotten used and tries to retain a positive outlook. Her positive outlook is so strong in fact that the student can't see the truth of things right in front of her. At first the story revolves around how Itoshiki and the student's different outlooks clash but the story becomes more about the class Itoshiki teaches. The class is filled with students just as odd as Itoshiki, and as each one is revealed and detailed their eccentricities build on each other.
You have to admire the thoroughness of the gags. Each students represents one of the typical stereotypes you can find in manga, and each chapter adds another one to the mix. What makes this stand out is that these stereotypes are not being used as a storytelling shorthand, but are used as if they were real continuing characters with consequences to their actions. The stalker's line of her own stalkers first show up in her story, then repeatedly show up in the rest of the volume as other characters stumble across them. The gratuitous panty shot girl continues to do them long after her gag is established. Individually the characters and their actions may not be special, but later in the volume when all of the gags start interacting and building on each other, they move past idly amusing then annoying into the land of being genuinely funny.
We post reviews of all kinds of manga - shojo, shonen, yaoi, manhwa (Korean), OEL (original English language), and hey, pass the Chinese too if you've got any - and we're a tough audience because we've been fans of manga and anime for over 15 years.
Rankings are from 1 to 5 stars, including halfs. That means a 3 is "average".
We post new reviews twice weekly, Tuesday and Thursday.
Full disclosure: Virtually all of our reviews are of publisher provided free copies. Considering some of the ratings we have given out, I hope you can see that we show no favoritism and little kindness because of that.
If you're willing to face that, publishers who want us to review their manga (printed books only, sorry) email prosperosmanga @ gmail . com
You can now find Prospero's Manga on FaceBook! REMINDER - REMINDER
If you want to do a general search to find something specific on Prospero's Manga, use the search box at the top left of this page.